Go Enrichment Error with Tutorial Dataset

Dear all,
I tried to run a GO Enrichment analysis with the datasets provided in the tutorial (https://galaxyproject.github.io/training-material/topics/transcriptomics/tutorials/goenrichment/tutorial.html). Nevertheless, I get back an error message in the initial graph and result files indicating: tool error; an error occured with the dataset; Failed to find or download one or more job outputs from remote server.
Does anybody have a solution for this issue?
Thanks a lot and best regards
Max

1 Like

Unfortunately I don’t have a solution, but I had the same problems with my own data. I got either the same error as Max described or that there was a mistake in one line of the obo file. I tried to reanalyze a datasets which I had successfully analyzed before (same tool, a few month ago) once more- same problem. Therefor I downloaded the trainings-datasets from the tutorial and got the following error: org.obolibrary.oboformat.parser.OBOFormatParser warn
WARNING: LINE: 475828 accepting bad xref with spaces:<MetaCyc: RXN-15910> LINE:
xref: MetaCyc: RXN-15910. Could there be something with the GO Enrichment tool?
Christiane

1 Like

Hi @Max @Christiane

Thanks for reporting the error and for all the tests. This does sound like either 1) a problem with the tool itself or possibly 2) a problem with server/cluster/resources running that tool.

For any urgent work, you could try running the tool at a different public Galaxy server to see if that resolves the error.

I’ll also be giving this a test and replying with updated info.

Ping to one of usegalaxy.eu admins in case there is a known issue I missed: @wm75. They may ask for a bug report.

Thanks!

Update Jan 25, 2021

The tool is working correctly at usegalaxy.eu again. Try a rerun for any jobs that failed (any error) or that have been queued for longer than a few days (the latter will likely never run).

For reference, the example history with the first few steps of the tutorial completed now includes a successful GOEnrichment run from today (Jan 25), and the two prior runs of that tool still in a queued state that will likely never resolve/execute (Jan 15 + Jan 18 tests): Galaxy | Europe | Accessible History | test GOEnrichment

Thanks @Christiane for reporting the problem!!


Update Jan 19, 2021

This tool is running slowly at UseGalaxy.eu right now – so no results there yet. That admin team is looking into it. The server may just be busy.

The immediate workaround is to run the tool/tutorial at UseGalaxy.org instead for now. Test history with the first few steps of the tutorial completed: Galaxy | Accessible History | imported from archive: test GOEnrichment

Issue ticket: GOEnrichment tool has extended queue state at usegalaxy.eu but executes at usegalaxy.org -- GTN tutorial · Issue #332 · galaxyproject/usegalaxy-playbook · GitHub


Update:

Apologies for the delay.

We are re-testing the tool and tutorial after a few recent updates (both the tool, and Galaxy itself).

A test history with the tutorial data and the first few steps (including GOEnrichment) are currently running. https://usegalaxy.eu/u/jenj/h/test-goenrichment

Let’s see how that test works out and follow up from there.